The American Presidency: From Revered Office to Political Punchline

Brian Sankarsingh wants to speak about the American Presidency

Photo by Katie Moum on Unsplash

The American presidency, once regarded as the most esteemed and powerful position in the world, has increasingly become the subject of ridicule, satire, and disillusionment. What was once a symbol of democratic ideals, leadership, and global influence has, in recent decades, devolved into a political joke for many Americans and observers worldwide. This shift reflects broader cultural, political, and institutional changes that have eroded public trust in the office and its occupants. From the rise of reality TV politics to the polarization of media and the erosion of norms, the presidency has become a lightning rod for criticism, mockery, and cynicism.

One of the most significant factors contributing to the transformation of the presidency into a political joke is the rise of celebrity culture in politics. The 2016 election of Donald Trump, a reality TV star with no prior political experience, marked a turning point. Trump’s presidency was characterized by bombastic rhetoric, Twitter¹ tirades, and a penchant for creating viral moments that often would overshadow policy discussions. His tenure blurred the lines between entertainment and governance, reducing the presidency to a spectacle that often felt more like a reality show than the administration of a global superpower.

While Trump’s presidency was unique in its theatrics, it was not an isolated phenomenon. The increasing influence of celebrity culture in politics has made the presidency more about personality than policy. Candidates are now often evaluated on their ability to entertain, provoke, or go viral, rather than their qualifications or vision for the country. This shift has undermined the dignity of the office, turning it into a platform for performative politics rather than serious leadership. Now in his second term as POTUS, and with full and unrestricted use to his social media app Truth Social, he has ramped up the rhetoric. His approach of throwing the wildest and oftentimes most hateful speech at the proverbial wall to see what sticks has effectively dropped the standard of the Office of the President to the bottom of the barrel.

The media landscape has also played a significant role in transforming the presidency into a joke. The 24-hour news cycle and the rise of social media have created an environment where sensationalism thrives. Outrageous statements, scandals, and gaffes dominate headlines, while substantive policy discussions are often relegated to the background. The presidency has become a constant source of fodder for late-night comedians, memes, and viral clips, further trivializing the office. News media no longer even try to maintain the illusion of unbiased reporting. Their biases are held out proudly front and centre. This polarization has exacerbated the problem. Outlets on both the left and the right often prioritize partisan narratives over objective reporting, turning the president into either a hero or a villain depending on one’s political affiliation. This divisive coverage has eroded the presidency’s role as a unifying symbol of the nation, instead making it a lightning rod for partisan attacks and mockery.

The decline of norms and decorum in American politics has further contributed to the presidency’s diminished stature. Traditionally, the office of the president was associated with a certain level of gravitas and respect. However, recent presidents on both sides have increasingly flouted these norms, engaging in behavior that would have been unthinkable in earlier eras. We’ve experienced Bill Clinton and the sexual scandal and now Trump’s frequent use of derogatory nicknames for political opponents, his public feuds with celebrities, and his refusal to concede the 2020 election all these examples represented a departure from the dignified conduct expected of a president. While Trump’s approach was particularly unconventional, other presidents have also faced criticism for undermining the office’s decorum, whether through partisan rhetoric or personal scandals.

The cumulative effect of these trends has been a growing sense of disillusionment and cynicism among the American public. Trust in government and political institutions has reached historic lows, and the presidency is no exception. Many Americans now view the office as a symbol of dysfunction, corruption, and incompetence rather than leadership and inspiration. This cynicism is reflected in popular culture, where the presidency is often portrayed as a farce. From satirical shows like Veep to memes mocking presidential gaffes, the office has become a frequent target of humor and criticism. While satire has always been a part of American political culture, the sheer volume and intensity of such portrayals today suggest a deeper loss of respect for the presidency.

Restoring the dignity of the American presidency will require addressing the underlying issues that have turned it into a political joke. This includes reforming the media landscape to prioritize substantive reporting over sensationalism, encouraging candidates to focus on policy rather than personality, and reaffirming the importance of norms and decorum in political life. Ultimately, the presidency is a reflection of the nation it serves. If Americans want to restore the office to its former stature, they must demand better from their leaders, their media, and themselves. The alternative is a continued descent – or spiral - into a political circus that undermines not only the presidency but the very foundations of American democracy.

In the end, the joke may be on the entire world if the American public and their leaders fail to take the presidency—and the responsibilities it entails—seriously.

Bio: BRIAN SANKARSINGH is a two-time award-winning poet and author. He is a Trinidadian-born Canadian immigrant who has published several books of poetry on a wide range of social and historical themes including racism, colonialism, and enslavement. Sankarsingh artfully blends prose and poetry into his storytelling creating an eclectic mix with both genres. This unique approach is sure to provide something for everyone.

Thanks for reading Seeking Veritas by The Professor, The Poet & Friends! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.